Recovery & Grief Support · aligned to Standard Evangelical (default)
The Empty Chair: Estrangement, Boundaries, and Grief at the Holidays
The holidays can press on the wounds of a broken relationship, but God draws near to the brokenhearted — and seeking peace never requires returning to someone who is unsafe.
How this lesson was made
DiviNav AI drafted this lesson (Recovery & Grief Support, aligned to the Standard Evangelical statement of faith), then an automatic review checked it for Scripture accuracy, theology, sensitive content, and originality. No pastor has read it line by line, so treat it as a starting point: read it all the way through and adapt it to your group before you teach.
Lesson plan
Greet everyone gently and thank them for coming — showing up when the holidays are hard takes courage. Remind the group of the ground rules: what is shared here stays here; we listen without fixing or giving advice; no one has to speak, and 'I'll pass' is always okay. Name the theme plainly: some of us are facing an empty chair this season — a relationship that is distant, broken, or lost — and that grief is real and allowed here. Invite a few slow breaths together before you begin. Briefly share the local help and crisis resources you prepared (see leader notes), making clear this group is spiritual support that walks alongside — not a replacement for — counselors, sponsors, doctors, and professional programs.
Read the three focus passages slowly, pausing between each. Psalm 27:10 (BSB): 'Though my father and mother forsake me, the LORD will receive me.' Psalm 34:18 (BSB): 'The LORD is near to the brokenhearted; He saves the contrite in spirit.' (Contrite here means crushed.) Romans 12:18 (BSB): 'If it is possible on your part, live at peace with everyone.' Invite the group to simply notice a word or phrase that stands out — no pressure to explain it yet. Let silence sit for a moment after the reading.
Keep this gentle and short. Name the reality: holiday tables can hold an empty chair — through estrangement, a relationship cut off for safety, death, or addiction's long erosion. That ache is grief, even when the person is still living. Offer three honest truths from the text, not pat answers. First (Psalm 27:10), even the most primal human bond can fail us, yet God does not forsake — He receives. Second (Psalm 34:18), God does not wait for us to tidy our grief before drawing near; He is near TO the brokenhearted, right in the mess. Third (Romans 12:18), notice Paul's careful words: 'IF it is possible' and 'on YOUR part.' Peace is our responsibility to pursue where we can — but Scripture itself admits it is not always possible, and peace never means handing yourself back to someone who is unsafe. A boundary can be an act of love and sometimes of survival; it is not a failure of faith or forgiveness. We can release bitterness and still keep a locked door. And for some of us, the locked door is one someone else closed on us, maybe because of our using. Respecting that boundary, and leaving the outcome with God, can be part of making amends. End by holding the tension open — we will not rush anyone toward a tidy resolution tonight.
Move through the discussion questions below at the group's pace, beginning with the warm-up and allowing space for silence. Let people share only as much as they wish. If someone becomes distressed, slow down, thank them, and gently steward the room — you are not there to fix, only to listen well. It is fine to spend more time on fewer questions.
Set an empty chair in view of the group (or hand out an index card for those who prefer privacy). Invite each person to silently bring to mind the empty chair they are carrying this season. On a card, they may write one of three things, whichever fits: (1) a word for what they're grieving, (2) something they wish they could say, or (3) a boundary they need to keep for their safety and peace. No one has to share what they wrote. Offer the option to read it aloud, place the card face-down on the chair, or simply keep it. Cards on the chair are never read; afterward, hand them back or destroy them unread. Tell the group: if what you wrote is about someone hurting you now, please talk with me after tonight. Close the exercise by inviting the group to speak together, 'The LORD is near to the brokenhearted' (Psalm 34:18, BSB) over whatever is on each card. Reassure anyone who needs a boundary that keeping distance from an unsafe person can be the faithful, loving choice.
Invite (never require) short sentence prayers or a quiet moment. Lead a closing prayer that names the empty chairs without rushing to fix them, thanks God for drawing near to the brokenhearted, and asks for courage to pursue peace where it is possible and wisdom to keep safe boundaries where it is not. Remind the group of the next meeting and repeat the crisis and local-help resources before anyone leaves. If anyone shared something that suggests current danger, find them privately before they go and make sure they leave with the DV Hotline (1-800-799-7233), 988, or a counselor's number. Send them out gently: you are not alone, and you do not have to carry this season by yourself.
Discussion questions
- warmupWhat makes the holiday season particularly tender or heavy for you this year?
- warmupWhen you heard 'the LORD is near to the brokenhearted,' what did you feel — comfort, doubt, longing, or something else? There's no wrong answer.
- digRomans 12:18 says 'if it is possible... live at peace with everyone.' Why do you think Paul added the words 'if it is possible' and 'on your part'?
- digMany of us have been told that forgiveness means reopening the door. How do you understand the difference between releasing bitterness and keeping a boundary for safety?
- digPsalm 27:10 speaks of being received by God even when the closest people forsake us. Where do you most need to know you are 'received' right now?
- applyIs there one small, safe step toward peace — or one boundary you need to honor — that would help you get through this season?
- applyWho are the safe people, supports, or professionals you can lean on when the empty chair feels heaviest?
Scripture
Psalm 27:10 (BSB) — Though my father and mother forsake me, the LORD will receive me.
Psalm 34:18 (BSB) — The LORD is near to the brokenhearted; He saves the contrite in spirit.
Romans 12:18 (BSB) — If it is possible on your part, live at peace with everyone.
Leader notes
Prep checklist
- Before the session, write down local crisis and support resources to read aloud: the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline (call or text 988, available 24/7); the National Domestic Violence Hotline (1-800-799-7233, or text START to 88788); the SAMHSA National Helpline for substance use (1-800-662-4357, free, 24/7); for any immediate danger call 911; plus local counselors, support programs, and any sponsor/recovery contacts relevant to your group.
- Because this topic (estrangement, grief, addiction, abuse) can surface acute distress, be ready to respond if someone shares thoughts of self-harm or an unsafe situation: listen calmly, do not try to counsel or fix, point them clearly to 988, the National Domestic Violence Hotline (1-800-799-7233) for an unsafe relationship, SAMHSA (1-800-662-4357) for substance use, and 911, and encourage professional help. Make clear that prayer walks alongside — never replaces — emergency or professional care.
- Reinforce confidentiality at the start and remind everyone they may pass at any time.
- Running short on time? Keep the welcome and the 'Naming the Chair' activity intact, but trim the Teaching to the three Scripture truths only, and in discussion choose just two questions (one warm-up and the apply question about a safe next step) rather than all seven.
- Set up the room with a literal empty chair placed where all can see it; arrange seating in a gentle circle.
- Prepare to hold tension and silence without rushing anyone toward resolution; avoid clichés like 'everything happens for a reason.'
Materials
- One extra chair to serve as the 'empty chair'
- Index cards and pens for each person
- Printed list of local and crisis resources (988, DV Hotline 1-800-799-7233, SAMHSA 1-800-662-4357, 911, counselors, programs)
- Bibles or printed copies of Psalm 27:10; Psalm 34:18; Romans 12:18 (BSB)
- Tissues
- Optional: a small basket or the chair itself as a place to lay the cards
This took DiviNav about a minute. Make one for your church:
Try it free — no card